After Party A's hard work, 49.08 million orders of China Mobile were scrapped

2022 year 5 month 12 Japan , Fogang County People's hospital issued 《 Fogang County medical community informatization construction project 》 Tender notice , The budget 49,109,712.00 element .

The result of winning the bid

2022 year 6 month 2 The bid winning results will be released on the th , China Mobile Communications Group Guangdong Co., Ltd 49,085,200.00 Yuan won the bid （ Difference from budget 2.45 Ten thousand yuan ）.

Scoring results ：

Complaint handling results

2022 year 7 month 26 Japan , Fogang County Finance Bureau issued 《 Decision on handling government procurement complaints 》.

One 、 Item number :GDHY2022-ZC030

Two 、 Project name ： Fogang County medical community informatization construction project

3、 ... and 、 Related parties

Complainants ： Dongguan zuochang Network Development Co., Ltd

Respondent 1： Fogang County People's Hospital

Respondent 2： Guangdong Hongyu Project Management Consulting Co., Ltd

Four 、 Basic information

The complainant is “ Fogang County medical community informatization construction project ”（ Number ：GDHY2022-ZC030） Procurement documents , On 2022 year 5 month 26 Challenge the respondent , The respondent on 2022 year 6 month 1 Reply to query on . The complainant is not satisfied with the respondent's reply , On 2022 year 6 month 10 File a complaint with this authority .

Complaints 1： The bidding document of the project is 20 Page price deduction , Violated the Guangdong Provincial Department of finance 、 Notice of the Department of industry and information technology of Guangdong Province on further strengthening government procurement and promoting the development of small and medium-sized enterprises （ Yuecai procurement 〔2022〕6 Number ） Regulations .

Complaints 2： The bidding document of the project is 24 Page technical part 、 In the technical proposal 1、 Belong to the negative list of finance “ Horizontal comparison scoring ”.

Complaints 3： Of the bidding documents of the project “ Business part ” The first item of the score “ Score according to the honors obtained by the bidder related to the project ” And item 2 “ Score according to the software copyright closely related to the project obtained by the bidder ”, It belongs to using awards of specific industries as scoring conditions , And specify specific patents （ Software copyright is actually software patent ）.

Complaints 4： The bidding document of the project is 24 Page business scoring table , notes ： A copy of the certificate with the official seal of the bidder shall be provided as the evaluation basis , Do not provide, do not score .” It has damaged the rights and interests of our company .

Complaints 5： The bidding document of the project is 25 Page network line upgrading and optimization capability （1.0 branch ） Score , notes ： Based on the relevant information notification documents issued by the administrative departments at or above the provincial level on the construction and development of Broadband Networks , A scanned copy of the notification supporting data must be provided and stamped with the official seal of the bidder as the basis for evaluation , Do not provide, do not score .” It has damaged the rights and interests of our company .

Complaints 6： The bidding document of the project is 25 The bidder shall be rated according to the medical related business qualification obtained by the bidder ：“ Medical related business qualifications obtained by the bidder , have to 2 branch . notes ： A copy of the certificate shall be provided as the basis for evaluation , Do not provide, do not score .” It has damaged the rights and interests of our company .

Complaints 7： The bidding document of the project is 24 Page technical parameter response （20.0 branch ）：“ The comprehensive score shall be given according to the responsiveness of the bidder to the technical parameters of the invested products ： Mark “▲” Each negative deviation of the symbol parameter is deducted 2 branch ; Unmarked “▲” Each negative deviation of the symbol parameter is deducted 1 branch ; This item is the highest 20 branch , Until the score of this item is deducted .”

The complainant requested ：

1、 Cancel the project 2022 year 6 month 2 The bid winning results released on the th （ The winning unit ： China Mobile Communications Group Guangdong Co., Ltd ）, Reorganize the procurement activities of the project .

2、 Deal with the reported person according to law （1. Purchaser ,2. Purchasing agency ） Violation of the law .

5、 ... and 、 Treatment basis and results

Complaints 1： A violation of the 《 Guangdong Provincial Department of finance 、 Notice of the Department of industry and information technology of Guangdong Province on further strengthening government procurement and promoting the development of small and medium-sized enterprises 》（ Yuecai procurement 〔2022〕6 Number ） The second paragraph of the first point . therefore , This complaint is established .

Complaints 2： Do not conform to the 《 Notice of Qingyuan Municipal Finance Bureau on printing and distributing the negative list of Qingyuan Municipal Government Procurement 》（ Clear money and purchase 〔2022〕2 Number ） Schedule No 17 The provisions of . therefore , This complaint is established .

Complaints 3： accord with 《 Measures for the administration of bidding for government procurement of goods and services 》（ Ministry of Finance Order No 87 Number ） Twentieth . therefore , This complaint is not tenable .

Complaints 4： accord with 《 Measures for the administration of bidding for government procurement of goods and services 》（ Ministry of Finance Order No 87 Number ） Twentieth . therefore , This complaint is not tenable .

Complaints 5： In violation of the 《 Regulations for the implementation of the government procurement law of the people's Republic of China 》 Twentieth , and 《 Notice of Qingyuan Municipal Finance Bureau on printing and distributing the negative list of Qingyuan Municipal Government Procurement 》（ Clear money and purchase 〔2022〕2 Number ） Schedule No 16 term . therefore , This complaint is established .

Complaints 6： In violation of the 《 Measures for the administration of bidding for government procurement of goods and services 》 Article 55, paragraph 2 . therefore , This complaint is established .

Complaints 7： In violation of the 《 Regulations for the implementation of the government procurement law of the people's Republic of China 》 Article 34, paragraph 4 、《 Measures for the administration of bidding for government procurement of goods and services 》（ Ministry of Finance Order No 87 Number ） Paragraph 3 of Article 55 、《 Procurement demand management measures 》 Article 21 and 《 Notice of Qingyuan Municipal Finance Bureau on printing and distributing the negative list of Qingyuan Municipal Government Procurement 》（ Clear money and purchase 〔2022〕2 Number ） Schedule No 17 The provisions of . therefore , This complaint is established .

Complaints 3、4 Don't set up , Complaints 1、2、5、6、7 establish , therefore , It is confirmed that the project complaint is established .

according to 《 Government procurement query and complaint methods 》（ Ministry of Finance Order No 94 Number ） Article 31 （ Four ） The provisions of , The government procurement contract has been fulfilled , Causing loss to others , Relevant parties may file a lawsuit according to law , The person responsible shall be liable for compensation .

6、 ... and 、 Other supplementary matters

If you do not agree with this decision , This decision may be issued from the date of receipt 60 Apply to the people's Government of Fogang County for administrative reconsideration within days , Or from the date of receiving this decision 6 Bring an administrative lawsuit to Qingyuan Qingxin District People's court within months .

Fogang County Finance Bureau

2022 year 7 month 22 Japan