Revision of Journal of Computational Physics

My postgraduate direction , Simulation of non resonant fish bone mode instability excited by high-energy particles .

One paper is the numerical simulation of non resonant fish model instability under the anti shear safety factor profile . He has been employed in nuclear fusion and plasma physics .

Now this one EAST Numerical simulation of non resonant fishbone model instability excited by high-energy particles is submitted to Computational Physics .

Now the comments return , It's a repair return .

The comments of the first reviewer are harsh , It should be overhauled .

The second reviewer didn't have many opinions , It should be slightly repaired .

Now the manuscript has been modified and uploaded to the website .

Nuclear fusion and plasma physics are cscd Level

Computational physics is cacd The core

Computational physics is relatively difficult to cast .

My second paper is a research based on the first paper . The first is to modify qmin Pressure gradient at , Get a pressure profile , In this pressure profile, the non resonant fishbone instability excited by high-energy particles is studied .

The work done by the

1. Analysis of the 1.0 To 0.6 Angle of projection , The influence of specific pressure of high-energy particles on the growth rate and frequency of non resonant fishbone mode .

2. Analyze whether different projection angles are fishbone models excited by high-energy particles or fishbone models excited by capturing high-energy particles .

obtain 0.6-0.8 It is a non resonant fishbone model excited by high-energy particles . This is also the theme of this paper .

3. Study the angle of projection 0.6 The effect of injected energy on the instability of non resonant fishbone model .

4. Nonlinear projection angle 0.6 Moderation distribution , Modular structure , The fishbone pattern sweeps up .

5. Moderation distribution requires an energy evolution diagram

It is found that the growth rate cannot evolve into nonlinearity , Small growth rates can evolve into nonlinearity .

Now we have replied to the reviewer's comments .

I hope the reviewer can accept the reply , And journals can accept papers .

I am working in the direction of non resonant fish bone mode excited by high-energy particles . Computational physics is organized by the Chinese Nuclear Society , Also biased towards computer theory . Because my major is software engineering , Computational physics is related to computers , If computational physics can accept , This is also an article in my major .