Discussion | has large AI become autonomous? Lecun, chief scientist of openai

lately ,OpenAI Chief scientist A word of , The whole machine learning circle is fried .

2 month 10 Japan , Elijah · Sartsqueville （Ilya Sutskever） A tweet means ：「 Now the large neural network may have a weak sense of autonomy .」

The argument lasted for a few days . 

2 month 13 Japan ,LeCun Even end up in person , Extremely firm and simple ：

「 incorrect .」

「 even to the extent that 『 Weak consciousness 』 In the table, trace adjectives , and 『 Large neural networks 』 The adjective in represents large , All wrong . I think this needs a large-scale architecture that all neural networks do not have at present .」

After tweeting , Various replies followed .

 

Toby, an AI researcher at the University of New South Wales Sidney · Walsh （Toby Walsh） say ：「 Every time this speculative comment is published , It will take several months for the dialogue to return to the more realistic opportunities and threats brought by AI .」

 

Vice president of Citibank 、 Deep learning expert Valentino · zocca （Valentino Zocca） There are similar views ： 「 AI is unconscious , But apparently , Hype is more important than any fact .」

 

Jurgen, an independent sociologist of science and Technology · Gutt （Jürgen Geuter） Say in the post ：「 It is likely that there is no factual basis at all , It's just a sales gimmick of a startup company that has run a large number of simple statistics boasting that it has magical technical power .」

 

This view was supported by software testing expert Michael · bolton （Michael Bolton） Support for , He joked that ： 「AI There is not necessarily a weak consciousness , But Elia is probably there 『 weak 』 Run the train with your mouth full , It may even be more than 『 weak 』.」

 

Leon, an associate professor at the University of information technology in Copenhagen · Delchensky （Leon Dercynski） Also open ridicule ：「 Somewhere between earth and Mars , There is probably a teapot flying around the sun , This is much more reasonable than Elia's fantasies . Because the regulatory framework of celestial orbital flight actually exists , There is also a precise definition of what a teapot is .」

 

Microsoft Norwegian data scientist 、 front DeepMind Researcher Roman · Verpakoski （Roman Werpachowski） Release the famous 「 I'm your father 」 I responded to this message in a graphic way .

however , After being attacked by countless people , Teacher Elia replied very nobly and coldly ：「 Arrogance is the ultimate enemy .」

  

In the finger of thousands of people ,OpenAI My boss Sam · Ultraman （Sam Altman） Show support for colleagues 、 At the same time, fight back LeCun：

 

OpenAI Chief scientist ： Shows curiosity and openness to mysterious ideas , use 「 Probably 」 Start the sentence ;

 

Meta chief AI scientists ： The opening sentence is arbitrary 「 incorrect 」.

 

Maybe this can explain the past 5 Mid year performance .

 

dear Meta AI Researchers , This is my email address , Our company is hiring now .

 

 

online celebrity LeCun I've never been in the habit of getting angry on Social Networks , Reply immediately ：

 

A company can indeed build faster planes every day 、 Break the flight altitude record , Doing these things can make your name often make headlines , These breakthroughs may also be of some real use .

 

But if the goal is to really break through the atmosphere and fly into space orbit , Then it needs to be in the condensate storage tank 、 Turbopump has worked hard on these unremarkable technologies .

 

If you don't believe it, ask musk .

 

 

Interestingly , Microsoft's deep learning research boss Devon Hjelm In conclusion ：

 

AI Researchers and students in the world , If you don't know yet , The following is the outline of this event ：

 

Except for the old-fashioned AI Companies spray each other and fight with each other , There is no meaningful substance in this matter .

 

You'd better ask quality questions 、 Be curious 、 At the same time, maintain a suspicious attitude .

 

  Then put aside the swords of these big men , AI Is there any sense of autonomy ？ What do you think of this Meta and OpenAI Mutual choking of ？ Please share your views in the message area . We will also choose high quality to share , To participate in “ Weekly comments are polite ” Activity selection .